As reconstructed from my computer, which Leigh and Casey were using to look up lyrics. So there might be some mistakes.
Patrick Nielsen Hayden and Steve with a Hat on guitar and banjo. Theresa Nielsen Hayden, Casey Blair, Leigh Butler and Kevin Riggle on vocals.
I Want to Sing that Rock and Roll, Gillian Welch
I Feel So Good, Richard Thompson
Althea, Grateful Dead
Steely Dan??? Or something with lightening in it?
All That Way, Oysterband
Oh, Mary, Don’t You Weep
by Bruce Springsteen Slave spiritual, author unknown
Down Where The Drunkards Roll,
Maura O’connell Richard Thompson
Look at Miss Ohio,
Miranda Lambert Gillian Welch Don’t Drive to Atlanta
Dream Cafe, Greg Brown
Lawyers, Guns and Money, Warren Zevon
The Other Shore,
Luther Barnes Austin Lounge Lizards
On the Other Shore, Austin Lounge Lizards
Old Blevins, Austin Lounge Lizards
I Want to See the Bright Lights Tonight, Richard and Linda Thompson
The Wild Rover, Steve in a Hat
Over You For Now, Whisperado
When I Was a Boy, Dar Williams possibly: Read About Love, Richard Thompson
Feel free to add anything else you remember in the comments.